Skip to main content

WVU faculty, students contribute to cosmic breakthrough uncovering evidence of low-frequency gravitational waves


MORGANTOWN, W.Va. – More than two dozen researchers with ties to West Virginia University have helped unearth evidence of ripples in space time that have never been observed before.

Members of The Center for Gravitational Waves and Cosmology

Gravitational waves travel outwards from a source at light-speed, stretching and squeezing the very fabric of space-time (for instance, making the length of a ruler longer or shorter, or making time tick a little faster or slower as the wave passes). The first evidence for these ripples at very low frequencies was identified by a cohort of nearly 200 scientists from the U.S. and Canada. These low-frequency oscillations happen with periods of years to decades, and were recognized through high-precision timing of cosmic radio clocks called pulsars.

Artist’s interpretation of an array of pulsars being affected by gravitational ripples produced by a supermassive black hole binary in a distant galaxy. Credit: Aurore Simonnet for the NANOGrav Collaboration

This result emerged from 15 years of data acquired by the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves, or NANOGrav, which includes many researchers from WVU’s Department of Physics and Astronomy and the Center for Gravitational Waves and Cosmology.

Of the 95 authors documenting this evidence in newly published papers, 30 are associated with WVU; 11 authors are currently at WVU and 19 at some point in the past, generally trained as undergraduate students, graduate students or postdoctoral researchers.

Maura McLaughlin

Maura McLaughlin, Eberly Distinguished Professor in the WVU Department of Physics and Astronomy and the Director of the Center for Gravitational Waves and Cosmology, was a founding member of the NANOGrav collaboration and serves as co-director of the NANOGrav Physics Frontier Center. She is also a member of the international team of scientists collaborating globally on the project titled the International Pulsar Timing Array.

“NANOGrav and its international partners have discovered the first evidence for a background hum of gravitational waves,” McLaughlin said. “The universe is not static and never changing - we are awash in a space that is constantly stretching and squeezing.”

A series of papers on NANOGrav’s findings and observations has been published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters.

Sarah Burke Spolaor

Faculty and students gather to discuss the recent NANOGrav 15 year dataset release, including Sarah Burke-Spolaor, Emmanuel Fonseca, Andrew Kaiser, Tingting Liu and William Fiore. 

“The papers describe the evidence as arising from a ‘gravitational-wave background,’ which refers to the indiscernible signals coming from many sources of gravitational waves in the universe,” said Sarah Burke-Spolaor, assistant professor at WVU who founded NANOGrav’s Astrophysics Working Group in 2011. 

Sarah Burke Spolaor

“This can be understood by thinking about a huge orchestra tuning up their instruments: you know it’s an orchestra, and know there are many instruments, but can’t necessarily make one out specifically. We don’t yet know what is giving rise to this signal, but our publications discuss several possibilities: supermassive black holes in galaxy mergers, cosmic strings, and relic echoes of the big bang.”

One popular theory is that pairs of supermassive black holes orbiting one another could be the dominant source of these low-frequency gravitational waves. The black holes are estimated to be billions of times the mass of the sun.

“WVU is one of maybe two or three universities that serve as a major hub for all branches of science contributing to NANOGrav as a galaxy-sized detector that is beginning to detect the gravitational universe,” 
Sarah Burke Spolaor

Supermassive black holes are believed to reside at the centers of the largest galaxies in the universe, although have never been directly detected. When two galaxies merge, black holes from each wind up sinking to the center of the newly combined galaxy, orbiting each other as a binary system. Ultimately, the two black holes also merge. In the meantime, they stretch and squeeze the fabric of space time, generating gravitational waves that propagate away from their origin galaxy like ripples in a pond.

This isn’t the first gravitational wave breakthrough involving WVU. Sean McWilliams, associate professor of physics and astronomy, was part of the team in 2015 that detected gravitational waves for the very first time, confirming Albert Einstein’s general theory of relativity. That finding was made possible by Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory, or LIGO, detectors.

But unlike the fleeting high-frequency gravitational waves seen by ground-based instruments like LIGO, the low-frequency signal observed by NANOGrav could be perceived only with a detector much larger than the Earth. To meet that need, astronomers turned a sector of the Milky Way galaxy into a gravitational-wave antenna by making use of pulsars, the ultra-dense remnants of a star’s core following a supernova explosion. When observed from Earth, pulsars appear to “pulse,” making them useful as precise cosmic timepieces. NANOGrav’s effort collected data from 68 pulsars to form a type of detector called a pulsar timing array.

Emmanuel Fonseca

“Gravitational waves were not directly detected until LIGO,” said Emmanuel Fonseca, assistant professor of astronomy and NANOGrav member involved in the new discovery. “But it could only observe gravitational waves within a certain part of the spectrum, like seeing gravitational wave versions of optical light when there are gravitational wave versions of x-rays. So what NANOGrav did was confirm the existence of gravitational waves at a completely different part of the spectrum.”

The team relied heavily on the Green Bank Telescope - the world’s largest fully steerable radio telescope – located in Pocahontas County, West Virginia for observation and data collection. The Arecibo Observatory in Puerto Rico and the Very Large Array in New Mexico were also utilized.

“Pulsars are actually very faint radio sources, so we require thousands of hours a year on the world’s largest telescopes to carry out this experiment,” McLaughlin said. “These results are made possible through the National Science Foundation’s continued commitment to these exceptionally sensitive radio observatories.”

Burke-Spolaor said this newest discovery is a testament to the University’s expertise and dedication to the space sciences.

“WVU is one of maybe two or three universities that serve as a major hub for all branches of science contributing to NANOGrav as a galaxy-sized detector that is beginning to detect the gravitational universe,” she said. “NANOGrav involves a unique detector — essentially using pulsars as a GPS system — and requires extensive work by experts on stellar evolution, gravity, fundamental physics, galaxy evolution and black holes. We have contributors at WVU who span that range. WVU’s close involvement with Green Bank Telescope has contributed a strong West Virginia-based network of scientists.”

Burke-Spolaor also applauded the skill and dedication of WVU students and postdoctoral researchers who contributed to the project.

Graduate student Andrew Kaiser, of Fayetteville, Arkansas, has spent much of his research experience exploring and characterizing sources of noise and signals in gravitational wave detectors. For this discovery, Kaiser conducted statistical analyses included in the published papers.

Andrew Kaiser

“I analyzed specific pulsars by looking at noise and timing in a very myopic way,” he said. “With that information, we can combine it with the statistics we use in our detections.”

After graduating with a bachelor’s degree from the University of Arkansas, Kaiser wound up at WVU because of its opportunities in the field of gravitational waves.

“There were really big exciting things happening in pulsar timing,” he said. “Coming to WVU to witness the triumphs of pulsar timing firsthand has been one of the biggest things for me.”

Jacob Turner

Jacob Turner, a graduate student from Chicago, Illinois, studies one of the largest sources of noise, the interstellar medium. He works to characterize the noise and understanding of the origins and then helping to correct for them in the detector. “It's been incredibly humbling and a privilege to work in this collaboration. It's a landmark accomplishment still hard to believe I'm a part of something so important. I began to get involved in NANOGrav as an undergraduate in 2015, and plan to work with NANOGrav as long as I can in the future”

Ross Jennings

Ross Jennings, a postdoctoral researcher whose research focuses on characterizing the instrument of pulsar timing, works closely on the noise budget which focuses on the exact arrival times of the pulses and how to improve the information of the shape of the pulsar that determines the arrival of the pulse. “It's really exciting to be a part of this huge team working towards the same scientific goals.” 

Will Fiore

Will Fiore, a graduate student from Madison, Wisconsin, works on the searching side of the project, including surveys with the Green Bank Telescope and the timing of the pulsars in the dataset. “We have the best dataset in the world; the most high quality data on these pulsars and so you can do very interesting astrophysics even beyond gravitational waves.” 

“Since coming here and joining NANOGrav, I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about using gravitational waves and multi-messenger observations to search for and study sources,” said Tingting Liu, a postdoctoral researcher originally from Nanjing, China.

TingTing Liu

Liu explained that light is a messenger of astrophysical information, while gravitational waves are another messenger. When two or more messengers combine, that produces multi-messenger observations.

The team said that future studies will enable scientists to view gravitational waves through a new window and how the universe evolved on the largest scales, providing information on how often galaxies collide and what drives black holes to merge. Researchers also believe that gravitational ripples of the Big Bang itself may make up a fraction of this new evidence, offering insight into how the universe was formed.



MEDIA CONTACT: Holly Legleiter Public Relations Coordinator WVU Center for Gravitational Waves and Cosmology 304-685-5301;